This is the single most common mistake on a landlord's tax return, and it is an expensive one in both directions. Checked against HMRC guidance in September 2026.
If you let residential property as an individual, your mortgage interest is not an expense you take off your rental income. It is a tax reducer worth 20% of the interest, and it goes in box 44 of the SA105, headed "Residential property finance costs".
Box 26 exists and is also about loan interest, which is why people land in it. Box 26 is for commercial property, and there the interest really is a deduction. Put residential interest in box 26 and you overstate your costs, understate your taxable profit, and file an incorrect return.
Before April 2017, mortgage interest was an ordinary deduction like insurance or repairs. Section 24 of the Finance (No. 2) Act 2015 phased that out over four years, and since April 2020 the restriction has applied in full.
The phrase people use is "you cannot claim mortgage interest any more", and it is wrong. You still get relief. You get it at a flat 20% rather than at your marginal rate, and it is applied after your tax is calculated rather than before.
A higher rate taxpayer with £20,000 of rent, £5,000 of running costs and £8,000 of mortgage interest.
£20,000 less £5,000 less £8,000 gives a £7,000 profit, taxed at 40%, so £2,800 of tax.
£20,000 less £5,000 gives a taxable profit of £15,000. Tax at 40% is £6,000. Then the box 44 reducer takes off 20% of the £8,000 interest, which is £1,600. The bill is £4,400.
Same rent, same mortgage, same bank account, £1,600 more tax. That gap is Section 24, and it is why the box matters.
For a basic rate taxpayer the arithmetic usually lands in the same place, because 20% relief is their marginal rate anyway. The sting is in the second-order effects below.
Because your assessed profit is now higher, the knock-on effects bite even when your income has not moved:
None of these are visible if you think of the interest as an expense. They are the reason a landlord can be no better off in cash terms and noticeably worse off after tax.
The reducer is limited to 20% of the lowest of three figures: your finance costs, your property profits, and your adjusted total income above the personal allowance.
If the cap bites, the unused part is carried forward to use against property profits in a later year. There is no time limit on the carry forward, so a loss-making year is not a year in which the relief disappears. Keep the figure, because you will need it.
The restriction targets individuals, partnerships with individual partners, and trustees letting residential property. It does not apply to:
From April 2026 you are submitting figures four times a year rather than once. A category error that used to be caught by an accountant in January now gets repeated across four quarterly updates before anyone looks at it.
It is also the mistake automated statement conversion gets wrong most often, because a letting agent statement or bank feed shows "mortgage payment" as a single outgoing with no hint that HMRC splits it three ways: the capital element is not deductible at all, the interest goes to box 44, and any arrangement fees are usually box 44 too.